What Taylormade Ball is Similar to the Pro V1?

The Titleist Pro V1 has long been the gold standard for premium golf balls played by professionals and better amateur players.

But does Taylormade offer a comparable alternative ball mimicking the Pro V1’s performance and feel at a more attractive price point?

In this in-depth guide, I’ll evaluate key similarities and differences between the Pro V1 and various Taylormade tour balls.

I’ll also provide my recommendations on the closest equivalent Taylormade model that stacks up favorably to the renowned Pro V1.

Read on to determine if you can save money by switching to a comparable Taylormade alternative to the iconic Pro V1 golf ball.

What Taylormade Ball is Similar to the Pro V1

Taylormade TP5/TP5x

As Taylormade’s flagship tour-level golf balls are priced similarly to the Pro V1, the TP5 and TP5x balls naturally draw the most comparisons. Here’s how they stack up against the Pro V1:

Construction

  • Pro V1 – 4-layer ball; urethane cover, mantle layer, casing layer, core
  • TP5/TP5x – 5-layer ball; urethane cover, dual-spin cover, dual-distance core, and stiffness mantle

Feel

  • Pro V1 – Very soft feel preferred by better players; crisp iron shots, soft putter feel
  • TP5 – Firmer feel unless perfectly struck; feedback on mishits
  • TP5x – Brighter and slightly firmer feel than the TP5

Greenside Spin

  • Pro V1 – Exceptional spin control from any lie; urethane cover grabs greens
  • TP5 – Very good greenside spin; prefers tighter lies to Pro V1
  • TP5x – Moderate spin; lacks on very soft pitch shots

Driver Distance

  • Pro V1 – Low launch, low spin for the ideal combo of carry and roll
  • TP5 – Launches higher with mid-spin; good distance
  • TP5x – High launch, mid-high spin; sacrifices some roll

Durability

  • Pro V1 – Very good for urethane cover; scrapes well but can still cut
  • TP5/TP5x – Not as durable as Pro V1; cover scuffs and cuts easier

Verdict: The TP5/TP5x are excellent premium golf balls, but don’t fully match the Pro V1’s optimal blend of soft feel, workability, and greenside control.

The TP5x does launch higher with more spin favorable for some players. But the Pro V1 remains the best-performing urethane-cover tour ball.

Taylormade Tour Response

As a tier below the TP5/TP5x models, how do these 4-piece Taylormade balls compare to the Pro V1?

Construction

  • Pro V1 – Multi-layer urethane cover, mantle, casing, core
  • Tour Response – 4-layer Ionomer cover, 3 mantle layers, reactive core

Feel

  • Pro V1 – Very soft, supple feel on all shots
  • Tour Response – Surprisingly soft feel but slightly firmer than Pro V1
  • Tour Responsex – Firmer feel with more feedback

Greenside Spin

  • Pro V1 – Exceptional spin from any conditions
  • Tour Response – Very good spin; slightly less than Pro V1
  • Tour Responsex – Moderate spin; lacks precision on soft pitches

Driver Distance

  • Pro V1 – Low launch, low spin for an optimized combo of carry and roll
  • Tour Response – Mid launch, mid/low spin; good tee ball distance
  • Tour Responsex – High launch, mid/high spin; sacrifices some roll

Durability

  • Pro V1 – Excellent durability for urethane cover; minor scrapes
  • Tour Response – Average scuff resistance; doesn’t cut as easily

Verdict: The Tour Response comes the closest of any Taylormade ball to mimicking the Pro V1’s feel and performance.

While greenside spin and durability aren’t quite as good, the Tour Response delivers outstanding quality at a discount to the Pro V1. Well worth trying for the golfer currently playing a Pro V1.

Taylormade Ball Similar to the Pro V1

Taylormade Project (a)

Taylormade’s 3-piece Project (a) model aimed at better amateur players also warrants a comparison to the Pro V1:

Construction

  • Pro V1 – Multi-layer urethane cover, mantle, casing, core
  • Project (a) – 3-layer Ionomer cover, mantle, and core

Feel

  • Pro V1 – Very soft and supple feel on all shots
  • Project (a) – Firmer feel, lacks the buttery softness of Pro V1

Greenside Spin

  • Pro V1 – Exceptional spin control from any conditions
  • Project (a) – Moderate greenside spin; less precision around greens

Driver Distance

  • Pro V1 – Low launch, low spin; ideal carry and roll
  • Project (a) – Mid-launch and spin; very good distance

Durability

  • Pro V1 – Excellent scuff resistance; minor scrapes and cuts
  • Project (a) – Average durability; covers scuffs and cuts more easily

Verdict: The firm ionomer cover prevents the Project (a) from matching the buttery soft feel and greenside workability of the Pro V1. Very good performance for the price but lacks the precision of urethane-cover tour balls.

Conclusion

The Taylormade golf ball coming closest to matching the iconic Titleist Pro V1’s blend of soft feel, scoring performance, and durability is the Taylormade Tour Response.

While no Taylormade model fully replicates the Pro V1’s characteristics, Tour Response provides excellent quality and playability at a discount to the Pro V1’s price.

Other golfers finding the Tour Response still too spinny off the tee may favor the Taylormade TP5x for its higher launch and moderate spin. But the TP5x lacks the full scoring control around the greens of the venerable Pro V1.

Overall, Taylormade offers a range of excellent premium golf balls with performance approaching the Pro V1.

But the king remains the reigning champion. The Pro V1 still can’t be matched for its total performance package blending soft feel, precision greenside spin, workability, and lasting durability.

Yet the Tour Response and TP5x models profiled here deliver outstanding quality in their own right at a friendlier price point.

I suggest avid Pro V1 players test these top Taylormade alternatives to see if the performance trade-offs are justified by the potential cost savings.

You may find a new favorite that enhances your game at a better price.

Similar Posts